While I agree with your post in general I think if you are going to talk about Jewish ingeniaty to Israel you should talk about Palestinian ingeniaty as well.
Which is to say that Palestinians are an ethnic not religious group consisting of Jews, Christians, and Muslims. They are the descendants of the people who lived there, canninites/jews/ect. If you have a group of people and some of them leave and some don't, whatever the status you want to apply to like the people who left and there category as "indigenous" it doesn't make the people who stayed less indigenous.
The claim of "Jewish Indigeneity" resides on a religious claim that somehow if you have two children and one them converts to another religion, that God steps in and strips that one of any right to the home. Because aside from God, its not clear why we should treat Jewish people in palestine who converted to Islam in the 1100s as less Indigeneous then ones who didn't.
Edit: phone won't let me scroll up to edit anything and does weird autocorrect shit. Sorry.
While I agree with your post in general I think if you are going to talk about Jewish ingeniaty to Israel you should talk about Palestinian ingeniaty as well.
Which is to say that Palestinians are an ethnic not religious group consisting of Jews, Christians, and Muslims. They are the descendants of the people who lived there, canninites/jews/ect. If you have a group of people and some of them leave and some don't, whatever the status you want to apply to like the people who left and there category as "indigenous" it doesn't make the people who stayed less indigenous.
The claim of "Jewish Indigeneity" resides on a religious claim that somehow if you have two children and one them converts to another religion, that God steps in and strips that one of any right to the home. Because aside from God, its not clear why we should treat Jewish people in palestine who converted to Islam in the 1100s as less Indigeneous then ones who didn't.
Edit: phone won't let me scroll up to edit anything and does weird autocorrect shit. Sorry.